Book review: The Synergy Solution

The Synergy Solution: How Companies Win the Merger and Acquisition Game. 2022. Mark L. Sawyer and Jeffrey M. Werners. Harvard Business Review Press.

“Poorly deliberate and executed acquisitions have nearly definitely destroyed way more funding worth than administration frauds.”

Traders who keep in mind large fraud-related wealth destroyers like Enron, HealthSouth, and Parmalat might surprise if this assertion is from Synergy answer: How do firms win the merger and acquisition sport? right. Authors Mark L And Jeffrey M. Werners Again up their claims, nevertheless, with examples like Conseco’s ill-fated 1998 all-stock acquisition of high-stakes cell dwelling maker Inexperienced Tree Monetary. A yr after the deal was introduced, Conseco inventory was down 50%. 4 years later, the corporate filed what was then the third largest US chapter petition ever.

Sirower and Weirens, who respectively head Deloitte’s U.S. mergers and acquisitions (M&A) and international monetary advisory enterprise, additionally present examples of by far probably the most profitable offers. For instance, Avis Finances Group inventory rose 105% within the 12 months after the corporate introduced that it will purchase main car-sharing firm Zipcar in an all-cash deal.

For buyers, the problem is predict the winners and losers from mergers and acquisitions. The authors reveal that one necessary piece of proof is the inventory market’s preliminary response to the deal announcement. Within the case of Conseco/Inexperienced Tree, the acquirer’s share value instantly fell 20%, whereas Avis Finances Group’s share value rose 9% in keeping with Zipcar information.

These aren’t remoted examples. Amongst its intensive experimental outcomes, Synergy answer It studies that in its pattern of 1,267 M&A offers from 1995-2018, acquirers with preliminary optimistic returns for one yr averaged +8.4%, in comparison with -9.1% for these with adverse preliminary returns. . Of the acquired shares that rose when the deal was introduced, 65.2% posted beneficial properties for the next 12 months, whereas 57.1% of those who fell upon the announcement had been nonetheless down a yr later.

Briefly, the market tends to acknowledge from the outset whether or not a newly introduced deal will add or subtract worth for the customer’s shareholders (and, for the customer’s shareholders, if the transaction forex is inventory). What explains this science? Sirower and Weirens use case research to make their argument: revenue is extra possible when the customer’s administration offers an in depth breakdown of anticipated synergies believable sufficient to justify the premium paid for the goal’s inventory (or the appraised worth, within the case of one other firm).

Conseco / Inexperienced Tree embodies the situation of the counter. Conseco beforehand generated the very best complete shareholder return within the S&P 1500 over a 15-year interval by creating 40 regional insurers. Administration has mastered the method of promptly lowering back-office prices, making synergies extremely predictable. In distinction, Conseco described its diversification into shopper lending with Inexperienced Tree as “strategic” and never cost-based. Traders did not purchase the cross-sale story, and the 20 % preliminary value drop proved to be a precursor. (The deal’s 83% premium did not assist both.) Conseco’s share value fell by half inside a yr and the corporate went bankrupt just a few years later.

Because the phrase “company” within the subtitle implies, the first audience for this e book consists of company executives and managers slightly than inventory analysts. However, the authors present very precious instruction on the exterior evaluation of whether or not a given M&A transaction is more likely to create or destroy wealth. to make this choice, Synergy answer Advocate complementing discounted money stream evaluation with financial worth added strategies. Sirower and Weirens present take into account an acquirer’s GAAP earnings, that are usually used to justify the premium over multiples paid in comparable transactions. Earnings per share generated for monetary reporting functions, for instance, could also be inflated as a result of one-off objects or trending down as a result of upcoming collective bargaining settlement renewals — a difficulty that’s presently rising in significance in gentle of rising inflation. Funding organizations with enough sources might also conduct the kind of industrial due diligence the authors describe for consumers, together with surveys of contributors within the merging firm’s key markets.

In offering these pointers, Sirower and Weirens topic conventional analyzes of mergers and acquisitions transactions to well-justified scrutiny. Opposite to the assumption that acquisitions are solely wholesome if they’re accretive to earnings, the authors observe the low correlation between accretion/dilution and market response. A lot scientific analysis questions whether or not acquisitions work higher when they’re in a “associated” or “unrelated” enterprise or one thing in between. Nonetheless, lots of the goal firms have interaction in quite a lot of companies and due to this fact test multiple field. Sirower and Weirens additionally cautioned in opposition to specializing in the expansion charge of the merging firms’ goal market. Market progress charge ie Serviceable By their joint operations could also be much less.

Though they categorize the drawbacks of poorly conceived or CEO-driven acquisitions, Sirower and Weirens stress their perception within the virtues of correctly deliberate and executed mergers and acquisitions. Traders can enhance their possibilities of separating the wheat from the chaff through the use of a few of the lesser-known instruments they describe, akin to fairness worth in danger and assembly the premium line. Additionally helpful is the e book’s calculation of the comparative efficiency of all inventory trades, all-cash trades, and mixture trades. Given the dangers, buyers ought to positively benefit from the experiences and insights it offers Synergy answer.

For those who favored this put up, do not forget to subscribe Enterprise investor.

All posts are the opinion of the writer. As such, it shouldn’t be construed as funding recommendation, nor do the opinions expressed essentially replicate the views of the CFA Institute or the writer’s employer.

Skilled studying for CFA Institute members

CFA Institute members are empowered to report self-earned and self-report Skilled Studying (PL) credit, together with content material on Enterprise investor. Members can simply register credit utilizing Online PL tracker.